4 min read

Repair or replace? How to decide when an old fridge fails

A practical way to weigh a sealed-system repair against a new, more efficient cabinet.

The honest answer depends less on the age of the fridge than on what has failed and what the cabinet is worth. A thermostat or door seal is almost always worth replacing. A leaked sealed system in an ageing, inefficient unit often is not.

Faults that are usually worth repairing

Thermostats, thermistors, start components, fans, defrost timers, drains and door seals. These are accessible, relatively inexpensive and restore the cabinet to its designed performance.

A blocked drain causing ice on the back wall is a common example: a straightforward fix that is often mistaken for a failing fridge.

Faults that need a cost comparison

Compressor replacement, evaporator leaks and multiple simultaneous faults. These are labour-heavy and the parts can approach the price of a new unit, particularly in older cabinets with poor insulation.

Ask for the comparison in writing, including the efficiency of a replacement. A newer cabinet can pay back part of its cost in electricity.

Age is a signal, not a rule

A well-built older fridge with a simple fault is often the better bet. A cheap unit that has already had two gas repairs is usually a false economy.

What matters is the condition of the cabinet, the availability of parts and how critical the contents are.

In short

Ask what failed, what it costs to fix and what a replacement would use in electricity. The decision usually makes itself after that.

Next step

Tell us about the property.

Send the suburb, what the system is doing and when someone can be there. Every enquiry from this site is tagged for Muizenberg and goes to info@reyds.co.za.

CallWhatsAppEnquire